Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Lake Geneva Woman who helped plan robbery that led to fatal Wheatland home invasion pleads guilty
topical alert top story

Lake Geneva Woman who helped plan robbery that led to fatal Wheatland home invasion pleads guilty


A woman charged with conspiracy for helping set up a planned robbery that ultimately led to the shooting death of Wheatland resident Joseph Riley pleaded guilty Wednesday.

Christina May, 43, of Lake Geneva, pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit armed robbery, a felony carrying a possible penalty of up to 25 years of initial confinement in prison. According to defense attorney Michael Barth, the plea agreement had May pleading to the original charge and the with the state giving no offer that they would argue for a more lenient sentence.

According to prosecutors, May and Riley were friends. After Riley, 23, was shot to death in a home invasion on May 15, 2018, May shared memorials to him on social media. “Most awesome hippie I’ve ever met. So down to earth, always wanting to help, always wanted to share love and peace with everyone,” she wrote.

But according to the prosecution, May’s actions had helped set the fatal home invasion in motion.

Taking some extra steps to secure your home before you go on vacation can keep you safe from burglary. Watch this to find out some easy tips on how to do so.

According to the criminal complaint, May was behind in rent and in need of money when she allegedly contacted Augustine Sanchez of Racine in November 2018 and told him Riley would be a “soft target” in possession of marijuana and cash.

The complaint states that May gave Sanchez Riley’s address and warnings that Riley had a large dog and a gun.

May told Sanchez she needed $1,500 for rent, and that whatever he got from Riley’s house beyond that he could keep.

Support Local Journalism

Your membership makes our reporting possible.

But on Nov. 14, 2018, when they were supposed to commit the robbery, Sanchez told investigators, May called him and said, “Riley was not selling marijuana today because his niece was over and so the deal was off for the night because she could not get into the house.”

According to the complaint, Sanchez, his brother and two friends were already on the way to Riley’s house when they received the call so they decided to attempt to rob him anyway. They were unable to get into the house that night.

The following night four men, including Sanchez, returned to Riley’s home to make a second attempt to rob him. This time, May said she no longer wanted to be involved.

“I had told them, I pulled out of it, I didn’t want to have anything to do with it, “ May told Wagner Wednesday. “They said we’re doing it with or without you.”

Assistant District Attorney Jessica Krejcarek confirmed to Wagner that May had been involved on the first-day of the planned robbery, but had backed out by the second day.

“When they told me they were on their way to go do this, that is when I was like I don’t want anything to do with this,” May told Wagner

“It would have been a homicide (charge) otherwise,” Barth said.

Sanchez and three others were charged with Riley’s death. Markeith Wilson, 22, of Racine, was convicted of first-degree intentional homicide and attempted first-degree homicide at trial and sentenced to life in prison. Sanchez, Anthony Harris, 25, of Racine, and Demarco Hudson, 21, of Racine, are still awaiting resolution of their cases.

May is scheduled to be sentenced May 17.

Sign up for our Crime & Courts newsletter

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

News Alert