Commentary: If Democrats dislike Trump's authoritarianism, why were the debates so hot for executive action?

Commentary: If Democrats dislike Trump's authoritarianism, why were the debates so hot for executive action?


For the nearly 1,000 days of his presidency, Donald Trump has shown the nation the dangerous repercussions that can arise when a democratic society succumbs to cynicism about its own government. It's not pretty.

Undermining norms. Installing anti-government figures to go at the bureaucratic framework like ravenous termites. Slashing tax revenues to "starve the beast," which lays the groundwork for budget cuts for programs that are suddenly unaffordable.

The federal government, to be sure, does have its problems. And the power politics of Washington is an appealing punching bag for those willing to see dark forces arraying against the little guy.

But as problematic as government can be, it is not the enemy. To warp the famous Pogo line, the government is us, and it will be as good or as bad as we decide to make it.

And in electing Trump, we decided to make it very bad.

Should the federal government be smaller? That's a legitimate and maybe even necessary discussion to have. But blowing up federal agencies in an anti-regulatory frenzy is not a workable solution. Government by its nature yaws as policies shift under incoming administrations. Republicans tend to favor less regulation; Democrats tend to favor more.

And we have regulatory rules to mitigate the excessive swings - air deemed too polluted under one administration really shouldn't suddenly become clean enough under the new administration. Decisions need to be based on research, and reason, even with changes in philosophies in the White House.

Until Trump. If Rudy Giuliani was a hand grenade tossed into diplomatic efforts with Ukraine, as John Bolton framed it, then Trump is a demolitions guy stacking dynamite in the government basement.

Can ousting Trump recalibrate the democracy? Probably not. He's contagious on some levels.

On the campaign trail, several Democrats have invoked using executive actions to achieve a wide range of reforms that Congress has refused to address. Elizabeth Warren, Bernie Sanders and Kamala Harris have all vowed to use executive power to achieve policy goals they might not be able to get through Congress, a strategy most Democrats have decried when the executive doing the ordering was Trump.

So in some ways Trump's excesses have created a norm for the use of power by a president, though in truth that is part of an evolution that predates the Nixon administration - the embrace of the "imperial presidency," in which, as historian Arthur Schlesinger argued, "presidents made sweeping claims of inherent power, neglected the collection of consent, withheld information ad libitum and went to war against sovereign states."

Do we really want a president to exercise that kind of power? Do we want a president to do, by decree, that which elected representatives have declined - or failed - to do legislatively?

This is about more than finding a way to ban combat-style weapons, something I think is vital to the public interest and that has been the focus of some Democratic candidates' threats to use the power of the office as the means to an end.

But that leaves us right where we are - with a system of governance by a handful of people, not we the people, which accelerates the feedback loop that feeds cynicism among the electorate.

As I've argued before, a democracy is only as strong as the people's faith in it. And Democrats who reject Trump's authoritarian instincts would be wise to make sure that in their zeal to oust him, they don't become him.



Scott Martelle, who joined the Los Angeles Times editorial board in 2014, is a veteran journalist and author of six history books.

Visit the Los Angeles Times at


Get Breaking News delivered directly to you.

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Another year has transpired and the Kenosha News daily announces passage of another veteran. The addition of an American flag bordering the de…

  • Updated

It's hard not to be reminded, on a daily basis, that racism in America is alive and well. One recent instance to make the news took place on Oct. 26 at a Buffalo Wild Wings restaurant near Chicago. A group of about 20 family members and friends, including several children, were approached by an employee who purportedly asked group member Justin Vahl, "What race are you?" When Vahl asked the ...

Katie Hill's farewell speech after less than a year as a member of Congress from California's 25th district was apologetic, to the people she said she let down, and it was defiant, to the people she said had set her up, who practiced the "gutter politics" of a "misogynistic culture," and who exploited and punished her with a double standard about sexual conduct whose male transgressors, she ...

Autumn has arrived and, with it, open enrollment season, when every person with job-based health insurance "chooses" a health plan. If you're like most people, you are struggling to figure out what exactly you get for your insurance premium dollars, how much you'll have to pay out of pocket when you need care, and which plan is most likely to meet your unforeseeable health care needs. We are ...

Even in our technologically advanced age, most reports of fires are called in by observant folks, often using cellphones. The ubiquity of these devices means an increased ability to detect wildfire more quickly. But a fair portion of California still has poor or no cellular coverage. Utilities that shut down power as a wildfire-prevention measure in fire-danger zones also render cellphones in ...

While impeachment inquiries rage on and the 2020 race heightens, we need not forget the policy battles we've been fighting for years that affect Americans, regardless of immigration status, each and every day. Since 2012, the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, program has shielded young immigrants who came to the U.S. as children from deportation, allowing them to legally work or ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.